Texas Contractor

Dedicated to the people who make our built environment better and safer. We tell your stories and celebrate your successes.

Register with us and receive industry news and content only available to subscribers.

Subscribe
Contacts

Indianapolis, IN, USA (HQ)

903 E. Ohio St., Indianapolis, IN 46202

Call: (317) 423-2325

info@acppubs.com

Knowing Your Rights and Options: A Guide to Contract Termination

by: JD Holzheauser, Peckar & Abramson, P.C.
JD Holzheauser
JD Holzheauser
It’s over. That’s the last straw. You have to terminate the contract. But do you? If the answer is yes, how? And what will happen? The answer likely depends on what you are allowed to do in the contract you want to terminate. Here is what a party should know and do if termination is an option. Let’s start with some basic information.
Termination in the Contract
You can only terminate a contract if your contract has a termination clause. If the contract does permit termination, you should conform your actions to the contract requirements.

There are often two types of termination clauses that can be found in a contract — termination for cause and termination for convenience. However, a clause allowing termination for cause is the most common.

But how do you know when and how you can terminate a contract? Look to the contract. A contract containing a termination for cause generally has three events that must occur before termination is official. First, the party to be terminated has committed some material act prohibited by the contract commonly referred to as an act of default. Second, the defaulting party is given notice of the default and, if the default is not cured, a notice of termination is sent to the defaulting party.

In a termination for convenience, the procedure is different. As the name suggests, the contract can be terminated for the convenience of the terminating party. In other words, there is no requirement of an act of default or even a reason for the termination. The primary justification is typically a “change in circumstances” and must be grounded in good faith. Typically, all that is required is written notice to the terminated party informing them that the contract is being terminated for convenience.

Termination for Cause
If you are in the position of the party who is terminating a contract for cause, what should you do? First, look at past issues with the other party throughout the project. Issues with productivity, work quality, manpower, delays, and other issues should be documented with contemporaneous correspondence. The documentation provides the history you need to assess the need and desirability of termination. If you do not have documentation, rethink your position.

Regardless of whether you have contemporaneous documentation, the following is a good practice. You need to understand the problem. You should talk to your project, review your project documents and correspondence, and assess the status of the impacted work. What is complete or incomplete? Is there any need for repair, replacement, or removal? Collect the project documents that record the current situation. You need to understand the situation. If the situation has been caused by something out of the other party’s control, like interference by a third party or changes in the scope of work, then you might reconsider whether termination is warranted.

Cementech
Your local Cementech dealer
Romco Equipment Co

Also, read the contract to fully understand the options you have for termination. If you determine you can terminate for cause, you should identify the process for termination, verify that you can follow the process, and follow that process.

Termination for Convenience
If you have a termination for convenience clause in your contract, you may prefer that option. As previously mentioned, the termination for convenience does not typically require the multi-step process of a termination for cause. Nor does it require the same amount of information gathering to back up a termination for convenience. Keep in mind that utilizing a termination for convenience typically does not result in litigation, but it likely precludes you from recovering any damages from the terminated party.

Read the contract to understand any limitations on termination for convenience. Some termination for convenience clauses will say they can be used at the terminating party’s convenience. But other termination for convenience clauses may limit the use of that clause to specific situations. For example, some clauses will allow the subcontract to be terminated for convenience, but only if the owner has terminated the contractor through no fault of the subcontractor. So, read your termination for convenience clause to fully understand the rights the contract gives you.

Responding to a Termination Situation
If you find yourself in the situation of being the party who is being terminated, or if you receive a notice informing you that you are in default of the contract, you need to act. Read your contract. Educate yourself on what the contract says. Know the rights and obligations you have, as well as those of the other party. Document the situation. Written correspondence with the other party and collecting supporting project documents and correspondence is a good idea. Communicate with your contracting party about the problems, issues, solutions, and actions that can be taken to avoid or stop termination.
Financial Consequences
If a contract is terminated, what are the immediate financial consequences? That depends on the type of termination. When a contract is terminated for convenience, the terminated party is typically entitled to payment for all work performed and accepted by the owner, plus any withheld retainage and other money owed.

When a contract is terminated for cause, the calculation typically begins at the same place, but the terminating party could withhold money to cover costs it incurred because of the default. The contract may also allow withholding all payments from the terminated party until the scope of work is completed by a third party. The contract will likely entitle the terminating party to recover from the terminated party all amounts paid to complete the relevant scope of work above the contract balance. In other words, after not receiving payment for work performed, the terminated party may also be responsible for additional costs.

Alternatives to Termination
Termination for cause can be expensive. If it is possible, you may consider other options before terminating. One option could be to de-scope the work with a deductive change order and hire an additional contractor to perform that work. Or you could supplement the forces of the struggling contractor. This may result in unexpected cost expense, but that could be a better option than the consequences of a termination for cause. Another option would be to provide financial support by entering an agreement to supplement their payroll. Or utilize joint checks to pay suppliers or subcontractors.

If your contract has a termination for convenience clause that allows you to terminate, that may be a better alternative than termination for cause.

A party terminated for cause is likely not getting paid everything it thinks it is owed and may be required to pay more than its contract value. That situation commonly leads to litigation or arbitration. A termination for convenience usually means that the terminating party pays what it owed to the terminated party. That is less likely to result in a legal fight.

Ultimately, termination may be unavoidable. But exploring your options is a good idea in almost every situation. Terminating the contract for cause may win the battle in front of you, but it could be the start of an expensive war you do not want to fight. Take care to evaluate your options and the potential consequences and consider all reasonable alternatives.

Finn
Your local Finn Corporation dealer
Romco Equipment Co